Molly MacKenzie 
Shaker Heights, Ohio
Ted Mosby (one-night stand)
|Gallery of Molly images (3)|
In First Time In New York, Ted tells Katie about his first time, in which he told Molly he loved her when he didn't, borrowed $20, and he never saw her again. But actually, it happened the other way around, she didn't mean it when she said she loved him.
Notes and Trivia
- In Ted Mosby is not a Jerk.com, the following is stated:
Letter from Molly Mackenzie:
- "Ted Mosby is most definitely NOT a jerk! He is a sweet, sensitive guy. I was the one who was a jerk. Ted was pure and innocent, so I manipulated him to get what I wanted. Then I ditched him right away, taking twenty bucks on the way out. Ted! If you read this, I am so sorry." 
- However it is worth noting that the website is non-official and is written by a fan.